Psychology Of Money II: Unlocking & Rewiring PT 2

 In part 1 we talked about reversing loss aversion and confirmation bias. Today we delve into more solutions to chase those financial demons away.

Reversing Herd Mentality

1. Develop Independent Thinking

   - Hack: Start cultivating your independent thinking by setting aside time for solo research before discussing your financial decisions with others. The more you trust your own analysis, the less likely you are to blindly follow the crowd.

   - Trick: Use a "quiet time" rule where you don’t make investment decisions immediately after consuming financial media or hearing about others' decisions. This helps you disconnect from the noise and focus on your own evaluation.

 2. Create Contrarian Goals

   - Hack: Set a contrarian goal that motivates you to think differently from the crowd. For example, aim to invest in undervalued sectors or seek out opportunities that others might be ignoring.

   - Trick: Try a "contrarian challenge" where you find one investment opportunity that’s unpopular with mainstream investors and analyze why it might succeed despite the crowd’s skepticism. This will help you reinforce independent thinking.

 3. Use Historical Case Studies

   - Hack: Learn from history by looking at case studies of market bubbles and crashes, like the dot-com bubble or the 2008 financial crisis. Understanding these examples can help you become more cautious about following the crowd.

   - Trick: Do a “what if” exercise where you imagine being in the midst of a past bubble (like the 2008 housing bubble). Write down what you might have done differently. This reflection will help you build mental models to avoid herd behavior in the future.

 Reversing Anchoring

 1. Reset the Anchor with Fresh Data

   - Hack: Reset your mental anchor by reviewing updated, objective data before making decisions. For example, if you’re fixated on a stock's past price, reanalyze it based on current fundamentals instead of its previous value.

   - Trick: Conduct “anchoring audits” where you periodically review your portfolio to check if any decisions are based on outdated price anchors. This helps you regularly refresh your perspective with current information.

2. Encourage Relative Comparisons

   - Hack: Shift your focus away from an anchored number (e.g., a stock’s initial purchase price) by comparing it to similar investments or market benchmarks. This broader context helps dilute the power of the anchor.

   - Trick: Try a “market review” exercise where you compare your investment to at least three others in the same category, without referencing the initial price. This will help break the original anchor’s hold and draw attention to current opportunities.

 3. Highlight Future-Oriented Goals

   - Hack: Shift your focus from past performance to future-oriented goals. Anchoring often happens when you focus too much on past prices. Setting clear future financial goals will help reduce this bias.

   - Trick: Implement a "future-first" strategy where you list your long-term financial goals before reviewing any past data. This will prime your thinking to be forward-looking rather than anchored in the past.

Reversing Overconfidence

1. Use Probabilistic Thinking

   - Hack: Start thinking in probabilities rather than certainties. This reduces the overconfidence trap of believing you "know" how a particular investment will perform. Instead of assuming a stock will rise, consider the likelihood of various outcomes.

   - Trick: Assign percentages to your confidence levels for different investment outcomes. For example, estimate there’s a 60% chance a stock will go up and a 40% chance it will go down. This exercise will help encourage humility and an awareness of uncertainty.

 2. Set Performance Benchmarks

   - Hack: Compare your performance to market benchmarks (like the S&P 500) over time. Overconfidence can fade when you see that beating the market consistently is harder than it seems.

   - Trick: Use a “benchmark tracker” where you record your returns alongside major market indices. Seeing your performance next to these benchmarks will temper overconfidence and introduce a more realistic perspective.

 3. Introduce Regular Reality Checks

   - Hack: Schedule quarterly “reality check” sessions where you review your past predictions and decisions. These sessions will highlight where overconfidence may have led to mistakes or missed opportunities.

   - Trick: In these reality checks, score your accuracy on previous investment predictions. Rate how confident you felt at the time and compare it to the actual outcome. This gap between expectation and reality will help you become more cautious in future predictions.

 4. Encourage Feedback Loops

   - Hack: Create a feedback loop where you receive regular input from unbiased third parties (such as financial advisors or peer groups). Hearing diverse opinions can puncture the bubble of overconfidence and introduce new perspectives.

   - Trick: Set up a “decision review board” where you present your investment ideas to a group of trusted advisors or peers for feedback before committing. This group can help identify any blind spots or overly confident assumptions.

 5. Use Pre-Commitment Devices

   - Hack: To reduce overconfidence in execution, use pre-commitment devices like automatic contributions or stop-loss orders. These mechanisms take emotion out of the equation and prevent overconfident decision-making in real-time.

   - Trick: Write down your investment thesis and make specific, measurable predictions before making a decision. For example: “I’m buying this stock because I believe it will increase by 15% within 12 months.” Revisit these predictions regularly to assess how accurate your confidence was.

---

By using these strategies, you’ll become more aware of how herd mentality, anchoring, and overconfidence impact your financial decisions. Over time, you’ll be better equipped to approach financial choices with clearer thinking, leading to smarter and more informed outcomes.